In Harmonium

Being in the main the musings of a Symbolic Anthropologist

When politics becomes asymmetric, symbolic warfare

| August 1, 2008

The personal is political Carol Hanish (?) I don’t usually write about politics. This isn’t because I don’t have strong political beliefs (I do) but, rather, because I prefer to devote my time and energies to other things. This wasn’t always the case, as a few of my close friends know, and I like to [...]

Objectivity, rationality and personal grounds of being

| July 19, 2008

One of the most interesting problems with any system of ethics is the twinned questions of a) what is the system grounded in and b) why should I, as an individual, care? I’m sure that most people are familiar with the old, probably apocryphal, story of a philosophy exam with one question on it – [...]

Some thought on rhetoric and rational discourse

| July 16, 2008

so when one dispassionately and accurately speaks of cluster bombing, depleted uranium, torture at Abu Ghraib, and laying siege to civilian population centres, the response is not that it is just “rhetoric.” Max Forte at openanthropology (NB: there is something weird with the cascading style sheets which interferes with italic script so I have changed [...]

Untangling Ethics: A framework for Anthropology

| July 14, 2008

In a recent blog post, Max Forte dissected the Human Terrain System’s (HTS) Top Misconceptions page. Now, in general, I have not been very kind about most of the attacks on the HTS and Max’s post is definitely an attack. It is, however, qualitatively different, in my opinion, from the majority of other attacks for [...]